Condition
Purchase
Sort by
Time
Various
Vintage cookie monster puppet - vintage,
$49.99
Buy It Now
Cookie monster hand puppet
$449.95
Buy It Now
Vintage 1980 sesame street - vintage,
$26.99
Buy It Now
Hasbro sesame street - hasbro,
$24.95
Buy It Now
Cookie monster hand puppet
$449.95
Buy It Now
Vintage sesame street cookie - sesame,
$17.00
Buy It Now
Vtg 1998 sesame street cookie - vtg,
$10.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie monster - sesame,
$43.32
Buy It Now
Vintage 1970s sesame street - vintage,
$40.00
Buy It Now
Cookie monster plush 2010 - cookie,
$5.00
Buy It Now
Sesame street muppets full - sesame,
$63.74
Buy It Now
Sesame street finger puppets - street,
$7.95
Buy It Now
Vintage mccalls 8527 sesame - 8527,
$8.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie - sesame,
$28.00
Buy It Now
Vintage sesame street puppets - vintage,
$299.00
Buy It Now
Elmo cookie monster - elmo,
$110.00
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie monster - sesame,
$39.98
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie monster - sesame,
$49.99
Buy It Now
Kidrobot sesame street plush - street,
$9.32
Buy It Now
Cookie monster plush puppet - plush,
$16.70
Buy It Now
Vintage sesame street - sesame, cookie
$12.00
Buy It Now
Vtg sesame street lot finger - sesame, 5
$25.00
Buy It Now
Cookie monster puppet - puppet, replica
$1200.00
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie monster - sesame,
$41.27
Buy It Now
Collectible gund sesame - sesame, street
$19.99
Buy It Now
Vintage cookie monster camp - cookie,
$19.99
Buy It Now
Cookie monster hand puppet - hand,
$16.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street gordon - gordon,, mr
$10.00
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie monster - sesame,
$12.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street lot - sesame,
$29.99
Buy It Now
Vintage 1980 cookie monster - 1980's,
$11.03
Buy It Now
Delightful cookie monster - delightful,
$40.55
Buy It Now
Gund sesame street cookie - gund,
$19.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street big bird cookie - sesame,
$6.05
Buy It Now
Vintage 1970s sesame - 1970s,
$31.00
Buy It Now
Vintage cookie monster hand - cookie,
$20.00
Buy It Now
Vtg 1998 arbys sesame - sesame, street
$12.99
Buy It Now
Vintage sesame street - vintage,
$6.50
Buy It Now
Sesame street official cookie - official,
$42.99
Buy It Now
Kermit cookie monster - 2, hand
$110.00
Buy It Now
Vintage 1970s cookie monster - cookie,
$24.99
Buy It Now
1997 applause cookie - cookie, monster
$27.50
Buy It Now
Vintage cookie monster puppet
$10.00
Buy It Now
Cookie monster large plush - cookie,
$90.00
Buy It Now
Sesame street figurine head - sesame,
$13.50
Buy It Now
Vth gund 2003 sesame street - 2003,
$28.76
Buy It Now
Cookie monster hand puppet - cookie,
$29.97
Buy It Now
Gund sesame street cookie - sesame,
$13.00
Buy It Now
Preschool cookie monster - preschool,
$26.38
Buy It Now
Sea world busch - sea,
$21.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie monster - street,
$41.27
Buy It Now
Sesame street puppets 2002 - street,
$12.00
Buy It Now
Vintage cookie monster - vintage, camp
$12.55
Buy It Now
Vintage gabriel sesame street - vintage,
$69.99
Buy It Now
Baby gund cookie - baby,
$12.00
Buy It Now
Vintage 1970s cookie monster - 1970s,
$38.00
Buy It Now
Vtg rare 1970s sesame street - rare,
$99.99
Buy It Now
Gund sesame street cookie - gund,
$14.98
Buy It Now
Cookie monster sesame street - cookie,
$18.99
Buy It Now
Vtg sesame street pvc - street, finger
$22.99
Buy It Now
Vtg sesame street cookie - sesame,
$19.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street finger puppet - sesame,
$14.95
Buy It Now
Rare 1971 topper - 1971, sesame
$68.00
Buy It Now
Vtg 1970s sesame street rubber - 1970s,
$15.00
Buy It Now
Sesame street the - sesame, cookie
$21.99
Buy It Now
Vtg gund sesame street - sesame, cookie
$26.49
Buy It Now
Sesame street 2003 - sesame, cookie
$19.80
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie - street, monster
$14.99
Buy It Now
Vintage sesame street finger - vintage,
$12.94
Buy It Now
Vtg 70s jim - vtg, muppet
$45.00
Buy It Now
Vintage sesame street - street, finger
$29.95
Buy It Now
Vtg 70s jim henson - vtg,
$69.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie monster - sesame,
$10.00
Buy It Now
Vintage 90s applause - 90s, cookie
$16.99
Buy It Now
Vintage sesame street cookie - street,
$10.00
Buy It Now
Cookie monster hand - monster,
$29.44
Buy It Now
Applause cookie monster - monster, puppet
$18.99
Buy It Now
Gund sesame street - street, cookie
$10.50
Buy It Now
Gund sesame street cookie - street,
$12.59
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie monster - sesame,
$11.31
Buy It Now
Lot vintage sesame street - sesame,
$16.89
Buy It Now
Cookie monster plush hand - 9”,
$10.00
Buy It Now
Fisher price mattel sesame - fisher,
$30.00
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie - sesame, monster
$36.99
Buy It Now
Ernie and cookie - and, monster
$41.99
Buy It Now
Vintage sesame street finger - 5,
$10.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street bert - bert, &
$19.99
Buy It Now
Sesame street monster hits - monster,
$20.99
Buy It Now
Vintage sesame street cookie - sesame,
$19.84
Buy It Now
Sesame street cookie - sesame,
$9.99
Buy It Now
Gund sesame street plush blue - gund/sesame,
$14.99
Buy It Now
Vintage red green - w/, eyes
$150.98
Buy It Now
Fisher price hand puppets elmo - fisher,
$19.95
Buy It Now
Gund sesame street cookie - sesame,
$34.03
Buy It Now
Elmo cookie monster 2 hand - elmo,
$100.00
Buy It Now
Kermit cookie monster - kermit,
$110.00
Buy It Now
Looking for more cookie monster puppet?
Search eBay live — fresh results filtered for the best value, updated every hour.
Browse 96 cookie monster puppet listings currently in our index. Prices range from $5 to $1200, with an average of $54.13. Whether you are hunting for a bargain or looking for a top-spec model, the selection below covers all price points — new, used and refurbished. More about cookie monster puppet →
Try this: catering trailers | british enfield | aristocrat slots | arkansas traveler boat | aristocrat slot machines | arf rc planes | antique license plates | antique cast iron beds | alien puppet | alien slot machine
Whether you are looking for a brand-new or second-hand cookie monster puppet, eBay offers one of the largest selections available online. With 96 active listings at the time of this page's last update, you have plenty of choice across different conditions, sellers and price points. The cheapest option currently starts at $5, while premium listings can reach $1200 — giving you a wide budget spread to work with. The average price of $54.13 can serve as a useful benchmark: listings below this tend to be used or auction-style, while those above often include extra accessories, warranties, or are sold by professional sellers with high feedback scores. Always check the seller's feedback rating and return policy before committing to a purchase. If you need the item quickly, filter by "Buy It Now" to avoid the uncertainty of auctions. For used items, look closely at the condition description and photos — terms like "good", "very good" and "like new" can mean very different things depending on the seller.