For Sale USA

Supernatural prop

4

Supernatural prop for sale on largest auction and classifieds sites

Home / Other Collectibles / Supernatural prop refurbished & used for sale | For Sale USA
Supernatural demon blade - demon,

Supernatural demon blade - demon,

$15.59
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural replica knife - supernatural,

Supernatural replica knife - supernatural,

$275.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural prop knife set - supernatural,

Supernatural prop knife set - supernatural,

$189.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural prop knife - supernatural, set

Supernatural prop knife - supernatural, set

$169.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Replica supernatural - replica,

Replica supernatural - replica,

$64.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural lucifer playing - supernatural,

Supernatural lucifer playing - supernatural,

$59.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Prop distressed jaw bone - jaw, with

Prop distressed jaw bone - jaw, with

$200.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Replica supernatural colt - supernatural,

Replica supernatural colt - supernatural,

$39.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural series prop - series,

Supernatural series prop - series,

$24.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural sam winchester - sam,

Supernatural sam winchester - sam,

$49.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural men letters - supernatural, of

Supernatural men letters - supernatural, of

$99.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural first blade prop - blade,

Supernatural first blade prop - blade,

$49.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural dean 1911 - supernatural,

Supernatural dean 1911 - supernatural,

$35.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural prop knife - supernatural, set

Supernatural prop knife - supernatural, set

$188.01
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural series t - tv,

Supernatural series t - tv,

$24.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Paragon prop replica - paragon,

Paragon prop replica - paragon,

$449.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural dean jack - dean, ryan'

Supernatural dean jack - dean, ryan'

$49.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural prop silver - prop,

Supernatural prop silver - prop,

$6.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural the colt - the, pistol

Supernatural the colt - the, pistol

$39.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Paragon prop replica - paragon,

Paragon prop replica - paragon,

$450.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural sam winchester - supernatural,

Supernatural sam winchester - supernatural,

$6.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural prop vintage - supernatural,

Supernatural prop vintage - supernatural,

$294.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural sam fbi badge - supernatural,

Supernatural sam fbi badge - supernatural,

$8.48
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural genuine uncut - genuine, gm

Supernatural genuine uncut - genuine, gm

$16.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural mountain range - mountain,

Supernatural mountain range - mountain,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Dean keyring prop cosplay - keyring,

Dean keyring prop cosplay - keyring,

$36.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural tarot card s01e12 - tarot,

Supernatural tarot card s01e12 - tarot,

$275.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural bobby fbi badge - fbi,

Supernatural bobby fbi badge - fbi,

$6.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural prop silver - supernatural,

Supernatural prop silver - supernatural,

$11.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural witch kill bullet - supernatural,

Supernatural witch kill bullet - supernatural,

$375.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural stunt angel - supernatural:,

Supernatural stunt angel - supernatural:,

$3495.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural david the demons - david,

Supernatural david the demons - david,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural dean winchester - supernatural,

Supernatural dean winchester - supernatural,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural gabriel poker - gabriel,

Supernatural gabriel poker - gabriel,

$59.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural sam dean - supernatural,

Supernatural sam dean - supernatural,

$475.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Good evil old vintage - good, vs

Good evil old vintage - good, vs

$100.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural series wendy - supernatural, tv

Supernatural series wendy - supernatural, tv

$24.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural the broken saddle - supernatural,

Supernatural the broken saddle - supernatural,

$495.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural prop replica set - prop,

Supernatural prop replica set - prop,

$170.10
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural demon blade prop - blade,

Supernatural demon blade prop - blade,

$35.09
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural props bullet - props,

Supernatural props bullet - props,

$299.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural dean winchester - dean,

Supernatural dean winchester - dean,

$4995.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural tarot card s01e12 - tarot,

Supernatural tarot card s01e12 - tarot,

$225.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural dean winchester - dean,

Supernatural dean winchester - dean,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural john winchester - supernatural,

Supernatural john winchester - supernatural,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural dean winchester - supernatural,

Supernatural dean winchester - supernatural,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural realtors jacket - realtors,

Supernatural realtors jacket - realtors,

$495.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural john winchester - supernatural,

Supernatural john winchester - supernatural,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Ladie carriage wrist watch - ladie's,

Ladie carriage wrist watch - ladie's,

$14.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural tarot card s01e12 - tarot,

Supernatural tarot card s01e12 - tarot,

$275.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural john winchester - supernatural,

Supernatural john winchester - supernatural,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural witch kill bullet - kill,

Supernatural witch kill bullet - kill,

$475.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural dean fbi badge - dean,

Supernatural dean fbi badge - dean,

$8.49
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural key resin - key,

Supernatural key resin - key,

$19.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural gerald hawkins - gerald,

Supernatural gerald hawkins - gerald,

$375.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural deans printed - deans,

Supernatural deans printed - deans,

$29.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural tarot card s01e12 - tarot,

Supernatural tarot card s01e12 - tarot,

$225.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Ladie quemex 18k gold - ladie's,

Ladie quemex 18k gold - ladie's,

$49.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural silver bullet - silver,

Supernatural silver bullet - silver,

$11.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural bullet screen - supernatural,

Supernatural bullet screen - supernatural,

$295.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural john winchester - john,

Supernatural john winchester - john,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural wheel inn key - inn,

Supernatural wheel inn key - inn,

$225.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural blue rose - blue,

Supernatural blue rose - blue,

$225.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural john winchester - john,

Supernatural john winchester - john,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural charlie costume - supernatural,

Supernatural charlie costume - supernatural,

$95.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural bob bighorn - supernatural, bob's

Supernatural bob bighorn - supernatural, bob's

$225.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Ladie cardini wrist - ladie's, watch

Ladie cardini wrist - ladie's, watch

$14.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural blue harbor - supernatural, lodge

Supernatural blue harbor - supernatural, lodge

$125.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural different dean - different,

Supernatural different dean - different,

$2995.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural john winchester - john,

Supernatural john winchester - john,

$195.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural tiki motel key - supernatural,

Supernatural tiki motel key - supernatural,

$775.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Replica supernatural equalizer - replica,

Replica supernatural equalizer - replica,

$34.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural call sheet - supernatural, and

Supernatural call sheet - supernatural, and

$125.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural printed colt - 3d,

Supernatural printed colt - 3d,

$9.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural great plains - great,

Supernatural great plains - great,

$225.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural jester costume - jester,

Supernatural jester costume - jester,

$875.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural crystal sands - supernatural,

Supernatural crystal sands - supernatural,

$225.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural the first blade - supernatural,

Supernatural the first blade - supernatural,

$24.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural crown motel - supernatural,

Supernatural crown motel - supernatural,

$325.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Enochian angel banishing - angel,

Enochian angel banishing - angel,

$24.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural the patricia - supernatural,

Supernatural the patricia - supernatural,

$195.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural charlie fbi badge - fbi,

Supernatural charlie fbi badge - fbi,

$7.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural call sheet and - supernatural,

Supernatural call sheet and - supernatural,

$125.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural call sheet - supernatural,

Supernatural call sheet - supernatural,

$125.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Nancy drew screen - screen, wraith

Nancy drew screen - screen, wraith

$1299.95
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural the stetson - the, motel

Supernatural the stetson - the, motel

$225.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural murray hotel key - supernatural,

Supernatural murray hotel key - supernatural,

$325.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural metatron marv - supernatural,

Supernatural metatron marv - supernatural,

$995.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural charlie - supernatural,

Supernatural charlie - supernatural,

$3995.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural dream collection - supernatural,

Supernatural dream collection - supernatural,

$5000.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural the willow - supernatural,

Supernatural the willow - supernatural,

$495.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural wizard oz - wizard, of

Supernatural wizard oz - wizard, of

$995.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural mary winchester - supernatural,

Supernatural mary winchester - supernatural,

$6.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural john winchester - supernatural,

Supernatural john winchester - supernatural,

$195.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural angel blade - angel,

Supernatural angel blade - angel,

$99.99
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored
Supernatural dean winchester - dean,

Supernatural dean winchester - dean,

$40.00
Buy It Now

» View on eBay #sponsored

Looking for more supernatural prop?

Search eBay live — fresh results filtered for the best value, updated every hour.

🔍 Search live deals
📊96 listings · from $6 · avg $395.65

Browse 96 supernatural prop listings currently in our index. Prices range from $6 to $5000, with an average of $395.65. Whether you are hunting for a bargain or looking for a top-spec model, the selection below covers all price points — new, used and refurbished. More about supernatural prop →

Try this: diecast huey helicopter | farmall tractor cultivators | old farm wagons | bike sidecar | vintage aircraft propeller | dirt modified race car | 1957 chevy cameo pickup | vintage rowing oars | lowrider trucks | grumman boat

Shop by budget

< $25 $25 – $50 $50 – $100 $100 – $200 $200 – $500 > $500

Everything you need to know about supernatural prop

Whether you are looking for a brand-new or second-hand supernatural prop, eBay offers one of the largest selections available online. With 96 active listings at the time of this page's last update, you have plenty of choice across different conditions, sellers and price points. The cheapest option currently starts at $6, while premium listings can reach $5000 — giving you a wide budget spread to work with. The average price of $395.65 can serve as a useful benchmark: listings below this tend to be used or auction-style, while those above often include extra accessories, warranties, or are sold by professional sellers with high feedback scores. Always check the seller's feedback rating and return policy before committing to a purchase. If you need the item quickly, filter by "Buy It Now" to avoid the uncertainty of auctions. For used items, look closely at the condition description and photos — terms like "good", "very good" and "like new" can mean very different things depending on the seller.

🔍 supernatural prop Search live on eBay